MacIntyre's comment shared in a previous post really gets to the heart of what I am trying to do with this blog, as well as another project I have been working on for some time. The purpose of this blog is to show how philosophy is not merely an academic discipline found in the classroom, but is rather a pursuit undertaken as a way of life, as something to studied as well as lived. Whether you are writing an academic paper, tilling a field, flipping burgers, painting a house, playing a game, or just having a discussion over a meal, you are engaged in a philosophical activity. Wherever you have questions about great ideas, are taking part in good conversation, or wonder about any basic concept, you are philosophizing.
The larger project I mentioned is one where I am taking a look at how philosophy has flourished in agricultural communities throughout history. I hope to provide some excerpts from the project sometime soon on the blog.
Sunday, July 8, 2012
MacIntyre Outside the Classroom
"We ought to require on the CVs of those who aspire to teaching or
research appointments in moral philosophy accounts of their relevant
experiences, on farms and construction sites, in laboratories and
studios, in soccer teams and string quartets, in political struggles and
military engagements. And we don't." Alasdair MacIntyre
Thursday, July 5, 2012
Philosophy Cafe
Ever since Socrates, philosophical issues have been discussed, debated, and defended in the public square. Unfortunately, for many people, philosophy has come to be seen as merely an academic discipline with no place outside of the classroom. With overcoming this mistaken sentiment being the springboard for this blog, I find the following article on public philosophical forums to be a heartening reminder of what philosophy is, can be, and should be. We think, therefore we are
Wednesday, July 4, 2012
What is Truth? (Part One)
This piece is written primarily as an introduction to questions about truth for beginning students in philosophy and for those who may not have had much experience studying philosophy. Because of this, the piece is not highly detailed, so I apologize to any of you who are more experienced in your studies of philosophy. Since the purpose of this blog is to bring philosophy out of the classroom and into our everyday lives, I think that introductory posts such as this one will better help us get acquainted with philosophy as a discipline and a way of life. I hope that it will stimulate some interesting discussion.
More often than not, you run into two opposing schools of thought when discussing ideas about truth, or "Truth," as members of one of the camps would have it. The members of these camps spend most of their time demonizing and criticizing each other, all the while ignoring any substantive questions associated with the idea of truth. These diametrically opposed schools of thought have both missed the point of how we can talk about truth. So the rest of this post will be an overview of the two camps. I will be providing my own solution to the problem in a later post.
First, I want to talk about the so-called, "correspondence theory" of truth. Philosophers who hold a correspondence theory of truth believe that if we are to consider something to be true, its truth must in fact correspond to reality. So, if you were to claim that all crows are black, some football players are from England, most Americans believe in God, or all dogs go to heaven, the truth of these claims would have to be verified by observing the facts of the particular state of affairs. Adherents of this view claim that it is the most reasonable way of approaching questions of truth since it provides you with an absolute standard by which you can measure if something is in fact true. This absolute standard, which many adherents refer to as an "objective" standard, stands in marked contrast to the second school of thought: relativism.
Relativism, in contrast to the absolutism of the adherents of a correspondence theory of truth, is the theory that there is no absolute conception of truth. Any attempts to demonstrate an objective standard of truth, according to the relativist, will end in frustration since there can be no absolute truth. There are many forms of relativism, so for the purposes of this piece I will focus on two: cultural relativism and individual relativism. Cultural relativists claim that the truth of a particular idea or statement depends on the culture or time in which it is expressed. For example, were an American to talk about freedom by criticizing another culture where women are subservient to men, the cultural relativist would claim that the American's view of freedom is true in the US, but not in that other culture. An individual relativist is someone who makes the says the ever popular, "what's true for you isn't true for me."
Now, why do I claim that both of these views miss the point? First, I want to highlight some of the positive ideas associated with each of the schools of thought. The absolutists rightly recognize that there is a standard way we can define truth, so that we can find a common way of identifying whether a statement is true or false. The relativists, specifically the cultural relativists, highlight an important insight on the nature of cultures. While embedded in a particular culture, you can find yourself accepting particular customs or practices which may not be accepted in another culture. This does not, however, mean that a particular custom is true in one culture and false in another; it merely takes differences in cultures into account in a way that many absolutists refuse to acknowledge.
The negatives of the relativist position tend to be more obvious to people, especially cultural relativism, since it would be difficult to condemn atrocities committed by one group against another if we were to completely follow this view. The problem with the correspondence theory of truth is that it does not take the passage of time into account. (With this problem of time, I am considering writing a piece on time in the future.) If there is a sense of things that are past, present, or future (have been, are, and will be), then if I claim "there will be a battle at sea tomorrow," we can only know the truth or falsity of the statement the following day. How do we avoid the problems posed by these opposed theories? You'll just have to wait for my upcoming answer in a later post.
More often than not, you run into two opposing schools of thought when discussing ideas about truth, or "Truth," as members of one of the camps would have it. The members of these camps spend most of their time demonizing and criticizing each other, all the while ignoring any substantive questions associated with the idea of truth. These diametrically opposed schools of thought have both missed the point of how we can talk about truth. So the rest of this post will be an overview of the two camps. I will be providing my own solution to the problem in a later post.
First, I want to talk about the so-called, "correspondence theory" of truth. Philosophers who hold a correspondence theory of truth believe that if we are to consider something to be true, its truth must in fact correspond to reality. So, if you were to claim that all crows are black, some football players are from England, most Americans believe in God, or all dogs go to heaven, the truth of these claims would have to be verified by observing the facts of the particular state of affairs. Adherents of this view claim that it is the most reasonable way of approaching questions of truth since it provides you with an absolute standard by which you can measure if something is in fact true. This absolute standard, which many adherents refer to as an "objective" standard, stands in marked contrast to the second school of thought: relativism.
Relativism, in contrast to the absolutism of the adherents of a correspondence theory of truth, is the theory that there is no absolute conception of truth. Any attempts to demonstrate an objective standard of truth, according to the relativist, will end in frustration since there can be no absolute truth. There are many forms of relativism, so for the purposes of this piece I will focus on two: cultural relativism and individual relativism. Cultural relativists claim that the truth of a particular idea or statement depends on the culture or time in which it is expressed. For example, were an American to talk about freedom by criticizing another culture where women are subservient to men, the cultural relativist would claim that the American's view of freedom is true in the US, but not in that other culture. An individual relativist is someone who makes the says the ever popular, "what's true for you isn't true for me."
Now, why do I claim that both of these views miss the point? First, I want to highlight some of the positive ideas associated with each of the schools of thought. The absolutists rightly recognize that there is a standard way we can define truth, so that we can find a common way of identifying whether a statement is true or false. The relativists, specifically the cultural relativists, highlight an important insight on the nature of cultures. While embedded in a particular culture, you can find yourself accepting particular customs or practices which may not be accepted in another culture. This does not, however, mean that a particular custom is true in one culture and false in another; it merely takes differences in cultures into account in a way that many absolutists refuse to acknowledge.
The negatives of the relativist position tend to be more obvious to people, especially cultural relativism, since it would be difficult to condemn atrocities committed by one group against another if we were to completely follow this view. The problem with the correspondence theory of truth is that it does not take the passage of time into account. (With this problem of time, I am considering writing a piece on time in the future.) If there is a sense of things that are past, present, or future (have been, are, and will be), then if I claim "there will be a battle at sea tomorrow," we can only know the truth or falsity of the statement the following day. How do we avoid the problems posed by these opposed theories? You'll just have to wait for my upcoming answer in a later post.
Tuesday, July 3, 2012
Descartes Work
I have been given the opportunity to work on a short piece on Descartes for an introductory philosophy text, which hopefully will be published next year. Here's to hoping that I do a decent job on the piece, and that the work is published. Ironically, I have always had a love/hate relationship with Descartes' work ever since beginning my studies in philosophy, so while I have been working on this project it has been interesting to see how my views have progressed over the years. Writing about so many important philosophical problems that can be traced back to Descartes' work has given me more of an appreciation for his importance, but it has also added to many of my deep seated concerns about Descartes' philosophy as well. We'll just have to see how the piece turns out, and hopefully sees the light of day.
Friday, June 15, 2012
Advice on War and Peace from "A Dance With Dragons"
George R.R. Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire series is full of intriguing characters and fascinating places, but it also has room for some very insightful philosophical and political ideas as well. While recently reading the latest book of the series, A Dance with Dragons, I came upon one of the best articulations of a philosophical caution about war yet in this series. Prince Doran Martell, while speaking to his vengeance-seeking nieces the Sand Snakes, makes the following observation:
"It is an easy thing for a prince to call the spears, but in the end the
children pay the price. For their sake, the wise prince will wage no
war without good cause, nor any war he cannot hope to win." ADWD 510
Something to think about when considering real-world situations, when there are those voices urging a rush to war at every perceived slight.
Wednesday, June 13, 2012
MacIntyre on Voting
Although written in 2004, Alasdair MacIntyre's article The Only Vote Worth Casting in November, is just as prescient now, if not more so when examining the options Americans have this year for presidential candidates. Here is a fascinating and important account of how we ought to view the lack of options for good candidates this election cycle.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

